Listen to This Episode

“When the Dream Is Still Alive, But Your Creative Confidence Isn’t“ on:

APPLE  | SPOTIFY | PANDORA

When the Dream Is Still Alive, But Your Creative Confidence Isn’t

There is a particular kind of pain that comes with being an artist when nobody is actually telling you that you are bad.

They are simply not choosing you.

No response to the audition. No reply to the pitch. No invitation. No commission. No opportunity. Sometimes not even a clear rejection—just silence.

And after enough silence, it becomes surprisingly easy to start answering the unanswered questions yourself.

Maybe I’m not as good as I thought I was.

Maybe I missed my moment.

Maybe I’m too old.

Maybe everyone else can see something about me that I can’t.

Why aren’t they choosing me?

This is one of the strange realities of creative confidence: you can still deeply want the dream while becoming less and less confident that you are capable of living it.

The dream has not necessarily disappeared.

Your confidence may simply have taken a hit.

And those are not the same thing.

When a Quiet Creative Season Starts Feeling Personal

I know this tension from my own life as an actor.

You audition. You submit. You prepare. You put yourself forward.

And then nothing happens.

I have decades of professional experience. I have trained, worked, performed, taught, and built a life around the arts.

And yet none of that makes me immune to the very human question:

What is wrong with me?

That is worth talking about because experienced artists sometimes believe they should have grown beyond self-doubt.

We imagine confidence will eventually become permanent.

Once we are trained enough, experienced enough, published enough, accomplished enough or respected enough, surely we will stop questioning ourselves.

But human beings do not work that way.

You can be highly qualified and still experience a loss of creative confidence.

You can know what you are capable of and still find yourself shaken by a long period in which nobody seems to reflect that ability back to you.

Artists Are Very Good at Filling in the Blanks

Silence is difficult because it leaves room for interpretation.

And artists are storytellers.

Unfortunately, we can become extraordinarily creative when constructing explanations for why things are not happening.

There was no callback, so perhaps I am no longer good enough.

Someone else received the opportunity, so perhaps I have fallen behind.

Leadership did not recognize what I could bring, so perhaps there was never much there to recognize.

The pitch went unanswered, so perhaps the idea was terrible.

But there is an enormous gap between an event and the meaning we attach to it.

A lack of response is not the same thing as a lack of ability.

There are countless reasons creative opportunities do or do not happen.

Markets change.

Budgets disappear.

Organizations restructure.

Leadership has preferences.

Casting needs shift.

Algorithms change.

Projects are cancelled.

Someone else happens to fit a particular need.

And sometimes we simply do not know.

The danger begins when we turn information we do not have into a verdict about ourselves.

Be careful about the story you write inside silence.

Creative Confidence Lives in the Body Too

A long period of disappointment does not only affect the thoughts running through your head.

Sometimes you begin to feel it physically.

The next audition feels different.

You are more nervous.

You second-guess choices you once would have made instinctively.

You walk into a meeting more aware of how you are being perceived than of what you have to offer.

You overprepare.

Or perhaps you avoid preparing because caring feels dangerous.

Instead of entering the room thinking, Here is what I bring, you begin wondering, What are they going to find wrong with me?

This can be particularly confusing for experienced artists.

You may actually be better at your craft than you were ten years ago while feeling less confident doing it.

Skill and confidence are related, but they are not identical.

Your experience does not disappear because your nervous system has become accustomed to disappointment.

Your training does not vanish because you are anxious.

Your creative identity is not erased because you are temporarily struggling to trust yourself.

A Confidence Dip Is Not Proof That Your Calling Has Gone

One of the most important distinctions an artist can make is this:

Your current confidence level does not contain the complete history of your artistry.

You are allowed to have a difficult period without rewriting your entire creative life around it.

You can be discouraged without being finished.

You can be tired without being done.

You can doubt yourself while still possessing genuine ability.

And you can temporarily lose confidence in the dream without actually losing the dream itself.

Sometimes you know the dream is still alive because you keep noticing it.

You still look at the opportunities.

You still have ideas.

You still imagine yourself doing the thing.

You still feel something when you watch somebody else create the kind of work you long to make.

You still write.

You still sing.

You still audition.

You still make things nobody asked you to make.

Somewhere underneath the disappointment, a piece of you still knows:

I have something here.

That does not mean you should blindly continue doing exactly what you have always done.

Sometimes the strategy needs to change.

Sometimes the industry really has changed.

Sometimes you need different collaborators, representation or opportunities.

Sometimes the organization, church, school or workplace you are creating inside simply is not a place where your artistry can flourish.

Sometimes you need a new room.

But recognizing that something around you needs to change is very different from deciding that you are the problem.

One is information.

The other is identity.

You Do Not Need to Feel Confident to Keep Going

Perhaps the most freeing thing we can do is stop waiting for confidence to return before we allow ourselves to move.

Instead of asking:

Do I feel confident enough to keep going?

Try asking:

What remains true about me as an artist, even when nobody is responding?

Your answer does not need to sound impressive.

It needs to be true.

Maybe you know you can write.

Maybe you know you have years of training inside your body.

Maybe you know you have something important to communicate.

Maybe you know you are still curious.

Maybe you know that creating makes you feel more like yourself.

Maybe all you can say today is:

I do not feel very confident right now, but I still care.

That is enough information for the next step.

Confidence does not have to be the admission ticket to your creative life.

You can take the audition while nervous.

Send the pitch while uncertain.

Make the work while questioning whether anyone will care.

Ask for the opportunity while part of you fears another no.

The goal is not to become an artist who never doubts themselves.

The goal is to become an artist who knows that doubt does not get the final vote.

Rebuilding Creative Identity Beneath Confidence

This is one of the reasons I wrote Audacious Artistry: Reclaim Your Creative Identity and Thrive in a Saturated World.

Artist life becomes incredibly fragile when our sense of self depends entirely on whether someone chooses us this week.

We need something underneath the roles, sales, commissions, applause, followers, invitations and opportunities.

A creative identity capable of surviving both the yes and the silence.

If you are in a period where your confidence has been knocked around, Audacious Artistry can help you go deeper into the questions underneath it.

I have also created a free 10-week group study guide to accompany the book. You can work through it on your own, with a friend or with a group of artists.

And honestly, this kind of creative struggle is exactly why community can matter.

Sometimes we need other artists around us who can remind us of what is true when disappointment has become louder than our own voice.

You can find the book and free study guide at LaraBiancaPilcher.com/book.

Before you leave this page and go chasing the next opportunity, ask yourself one question:

What remains true about my artistry, even when nobody is responding?

Start there.

The dream may still be very much alive.

Your confidence might simply need time—and a little help—to catch back up.

Go Deeper with Audacious Artistry

If this episode spoke to something in you, my book Audacious Artistry: Reclaim Your Creative Identity and Thrive in a Saturated World goes deeper.

This article is adapted from the Healthy Wealthy Wise Artist Podcast episode:

Listen to This Episode

“When the Dream Is Still Alive, But Your Creative Confidence Isn’t“ on:

APPLE  | SPOTIFY | PANDORA

Or visit the podcast page:
https://larabiancapilcher.com/podcast

With you as you keep creating,
— Lara Bianca Pilcher

---

Connect with Lara

Website:
https://larabiancapilcher.com

Instagram:
https://instagram.com/larabiancapilcher